The best budget ice maker under $200 works really well these days, proving that you don’t need to spend a lot for good ice. I’ve tested many cheap models and found that they’ve gotten much better recently. They make ice faster, produce clearer ice, and last longer than before—all while staying affordable.
You don’t have to give up nice features when buying a cheap ice maker. Today’s budget models offer different ice sizes, easy-to-use controls, and quiet running. These affordable machines work great for parties or small kitchens, giving you plenty of ice without emptying your wallet.
Related posts:
Best Budget Ice Maker Comparison: Our Top Picks at a Glance
The comparison table below presents essential data I’ve organized with AI assistance to simplify your decision-making process. I’ve strategically highlighted three key factors: price (confirming all models fall under $200), capacity, and ice type (bullet, cube, or nugget) to match your preference. While this provides a quick reference guide, you’ll find comprehensive analysis of each model in the detailed reviews that follow.
| Model | Price | Daily Production | Ice Type | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
Frigidaire EFIC121 | $99 | 26 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Euhomy IM-06D | $70 | 26 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Sweetcrispy Countertop Ice Maker | $65 | 26.5 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Frigidaire EFIC189 | $95 | 26 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Igloo ICEB33SS | $110 | 33 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Euhomy IM-12S-HM | $230 | 34 lbs | Nugget Ice | Read more |
 |
Crzoe JX-15NH-GY | $169 | 26 lbs | Nugget Ice | Read more |
 |
NewAir AI-100SS | $199 | 28 lbs | Bullet Ice | Read more |
 |
Erivess ZBJ-3 | $189 | 120 lbs | Cube Ice | Read more |
 |
Euhomy CIM011-70BL | $199 | 70 lbs | Cube Ice | Read more |
Best Budget Ice Maker Under $200
My Pick
When you’re shopping for an ice maker on a tight budget, you want the most bang for your buck without sacrificing quality. The Frigidaire EFIC121 stands out as the top choice for anyone watching their wallet while still needing reliable ice production.
What makes this model special is its generous ice storage capacity. You’ll be surprised to find that it holds just as much ice as models that cost $100 more. This means fewer trips to empty the bin during parties or family gatherings. The bullet ice it produces has a slightly softer texture than competitors, making it perfect for quickly cooling drinks without watering them down too much.
Frigidaire has been a trusted name in American homes since 1918 when it began producing refrigerators in Fort Wayne, Indiana. This long history of cooling expertise shows in even their budget offerings. Unlike many unfamiliar brands flooding online marketplaces, Frigidaire brings reliability and customer service backing that gives peace of mind with your purchase.
The simple controls make this ice maker easy to use right out of the box – no complicated setup or confusing buttons to figure out. Just add water, press start, and you’ll have your first batch of ice in minutes. The compact size fits nicely on most countertops without taking up too much space in smaller kitchens or dorm rooms.
For families on a budget, students in dorms, or anyone looking to save money while still getting quality ice, the Frigidaire EFIC121 offers the best value under $200, heck, even under $100. It delivers what matters most: plenty of ice when you need it, from a brand you can trust, at a price that won’t break the bank.
Under $100
Most Affordable Budget Ice Maker
The Euhomy IM-06D stands as the most affordable entry point in our ice maker lineup, earning its spot as Amazon’s Best Seller thanks to its undeniable cheap price point. This model offers a way to enjoy homemade ice without spending much, perfect for anyone watching their budget closely.
The Euhomy IM-06D stands as the most affordable entry point in our ice maker lineup, earning its spot as Amazon’s Best Seller thanks to its undeniable cheap price point. This model offers a way to enjoy homemade ice without spending much, perfect for anyone watching their budget closely.
Quality concerns might cross your mind with such a low price tag. Truth be told, nearly every countertop ice maker available today comes from Ningbo, China, regardless of the brand name you can find on title, or ice maker’s body. Brand name and customer support often make the difference rather than manufacturing location.
The Euhomy gains an advantage over mystery brands by being a company you can actually contact if problems arise. Amazon’s 30-day refund policy adds another safety net if you receive a faulty unit. This combination of accessible customer service and return protection reduces purchasing risk despite its budget status.
I guarantee that the Euhomy IM-06D is able to deliver the basics. It simply makes ice at the lowest possible price point – sometimes that’s exactly what we need.
Even More Affordable Budget Ice Maker
The Sweetcrispy Countertop Ice Maker represents the absolute bottom floor of ice maker pricing, coming in roughly 30% cheaper than the already budget-friendly Euhomy IM-06D. This price drop occurs because the Sweetcrispy is actually the same machine as the Euhomy – just without the branded name printed on the device. It doesn’t include a model name, or prints “Sweercrispy” on the product.
Both ice makers come from the same factories in China, containing identical internal components and production capabilities. The only real difference lies in the label and the price tag.
Amazon’s 30-day refund policy still applies to this unbranded version, providing the same safety net as with more expensive models. Should any issues arise, returning the product remains straightforward through Amazon’s standard process.
The lack of brand recognition translates directly into significant savings. Many households simply need functional ice production without paying extra for a recognized name on the machine. The Sweetcrispy delivers exactly this – basic ice making capability at the absolute minimum price point.
Budget-conscious shoppers might appreciate knowing this secret: many “different” ice makers at varying price points are often identical machines with different labels attached. This particular model cuts through the marketing to deliver the same performance at the lowest possible cost.
Alternative to the Best Budget Ice Maker
The Frigidaire EFIC189 offers an excellent compromise between quality and cost, standing as a more affordable sibling to my pick of the best Frigidaire EFIC121l. This unit carries the same trusted Frigidaire heritage but comes with a slightly lower price tag.
Cost savings primarily come from its more straightforward design. The Frigidaire EFIC189 skips some of the designs found on the EFIC121, choosing instead for a more practical approach to design. Despite these visual differences, the actual ice quality remains virtually identical – you’ll still get the same soft bullet ice that cools drinks quickly.
Many buyers might wonder if the extra cost of the Frigidaire EFIC121 is truly necessary. The ice production capacity and speed closely match its more expensive counterpart, making the Frigidaire EFIC189 the best budget ice maker, same for budget-conscious shoppers. The internal components share much of the same engineering, just packaged in a slightly different shell. I would pick this ice maker if it’s cheaper, as simple as that.
The reliable American brand backing still provides peace of mind even at this lower price point. Those looking to maximize value without sacrificing performance will find the Frigidaire EFIC189 hits a sweet spot – delivering quality ice from a trusted manufacturer without the premium price markup.
Another Option to the Best Budget Ice Maker
The Igloo ICEB33 presents another solid contender in the sub-$100 price category. Igloo has been cooling American drinks since 1947, starting with metal water coolers and growing into one of the most recognizable cooler brands in the United States. This experience with cooling technology shows in their venture into ice makers.
This budget-friendly model produces the same soft bullet ice found in the Frigidaire models, making it ideal for quickly cooling beverages without excessive dilution. The texture and melt rate remain comparable to more expensive options.
Price comparisons between this and other models should be a regular practice before making any purchase. The market for these budget ice makers fluctuates frequently, with the Igloo sometimes dropping below competitors during sales events.
Unlike other basic models, the Igloo ICEB33 offers a wide range of colors to choose from, adding a touch of personality while keeping costs low. This practical design maintains all the essential ice-making capabilities needed without adding expensive features that drive up the price.
Anyone searching for quality ice production at minimal cost will appreciate having the Igloo ICEB33 as an option to consider. Whether you get the Igloo or the Frigidaire is entirely up to which design and price tag are more appealing.
Under $200
Best Budget Nugget Ice Maker
The Euhomy IM-12S-HM stands out as the most affordable nugget ice maker available, though stepping into nugget ice territory means crossing the $100 price point. Nugget ice commands a premium due to its specialized production process, but this Euhomy model brings the popular ice type down to a more accessible price range.
Euhomy has rapidly climbed to become Amazon’s most popular ice maker brand, with thousands of positive reviews across their product line. Their rock-bottom prices have drawn in many buyers who just need an ice maker that works without breaking the bank.
The nugget ice from this machine offers that chewable texture that many enjoy with their smoothies. One notable characteristic is its quick melt rate – the airy composition that makes it so pleasantly chewable also means it dissolves faster in drinks than harder ice types.
You can finally enjoy chewable nugget ice at home without spending a fortune. Most other nugget ice makers cost way more, but this one gets the job done at a price that won’t hurt your wallet.
Actually the Lowest Budget Nugget Ice Maker
The Crzoe JX-15NH-GY claims the title of absolute lowest budget nugget ice maker on the market. This unbranded machine is actually identical to the Euhomy IM-12S-HM – they share the same internal components, same production method, and same ice quality, just without the Euhomy name printed on the exterior.
The missing brand name means you pay a lot less, plain and simple. You still get the same soft, chewable nugget ice that people love – just without paying extra for a logo on the machine.
Buying an unbranded ice maker isn’t really a gamble in quality since both machines maybe come from the same manufacturing factory in China. The components inside remain identical despite the price difference.
Amazon’s standard 30-day refund policy still applies, providing the same protection you’d get with the branded version. Should any issues arise, the return process works exactly the same way.
The quick-melting, soft nugget ice comes at the absolute minimum price point possible through this unbranded option. Smart shoppers often choose these OEM versions after realizing they’re paying extra just for a name on the machine rather than any actual performance differences.
Good Durability among the Budget Ice Maker
Are you ready to spend a bit more to guarantee a long-lasting ice maker? The NewAir AI-100SS sits at a slightly higher price point than other budget options but offers something many cheaper machines don’t – reliability that lasts.
NewAir is just like Euhomy – another Chinese brand with an American-sounding name. They disclose the origin of their ice makers, but they’ve been around long enough that more people know their name. The 1-year warranty gives you some backup if anything goes wrong.
In my years running a repair shop, I’ve seen far fewer NewAir units come in with problems than any other brand. When counting ice maker repairs, NewAir models simply don’t show up as often as the competition.
The bullet ice produced works perfectly for everyday drinks. The machine itself stays relatively quiet during operation, making it suitable for open kitchen layouts.
The extra investment pays off through extended lifespan alone – replacing a cheap ice maker every year ultimately costs more than buying one quality machine that lasts several years.
Best Affordable Undercounter Ice Maker
The Erivess ZBJ-3 offers a cheap way to get an ice maker that fits under your counter. Most built-in ice makers cost a lot more, but this one does the same job for less money. It’s exactly the same machine as the Euhomy IM-02 – you’re just not paying extra for the fancy name.
Having an ice maker tucked under your counter looks way better than one sitting on top. Your kitchen stays neater, and you free up counter space. The best part? This Erivess model gives you that built-in look without the usual high price tag.
The medium ice cubes it produces strike a nice balance – clear enough to look good in drinks without the cloudy appearance of the cheapest models. This moderate clarity means your beverages stay cold without excessive dilution.
Value seekers can feel confident knowing they’re getting exactly the same internal components as the Euhomy version. The price difference simply reflects the absence of brand recognition rather than any actual performance variations.
The stainless steel front panel gives this budget model a surprisingly premium appearance that blends well with other kitchen appliances. This makes it an excellent choice for anyone wanting to upgrade their kitchen’s functionality without the usual high cost of built-in appliances.
Another Budget Undercounter Ice Maker
Best Budget Undercounter Ice Maker
The Euhomy CIM011-70BL gives you a trusted brand name without emptying your wallet. For shoppers who feel more comfortable buying from a recognized company like Euhomy but need something more affordable, this compact model hits the sweet spot.
This smaller version trades some ice capacity for a lower price tag compared to its bigger brother, the Euhomy IM-02. The size reduction makes sense for singles, couples, or anyone with limited kitchen space who doesn’t need industrial amounts of ice.
You still get the same quality ice cubes with good clarity – not cloudy like the cheapest brands but clear enough to look nice in your drinks. The medium-sized cubes strike a good balance between cooling power and not watering down your beverages too quickly.
Euhomy keeps all the useful features from their pricier models in this budget version. The controls remain simple to use, and the machine runs quietly enough not to disturb conversations in the kitchen.
The sleek design looks more expensive than it actually is, making it a nice addition to any kitchen counter. This model proves you don’t need to compromise on looks or basic functionality when shopping on a tight budget. Moreover, the undercounter ice maker is usually more durable than a countertop one, thanks to its bigger space for its compressor.
What Is a Budget Ice Maker?
What Makes an Ice Maker “Budget”
The term “budget ice maker” encompasses more than simple price categorization—it reflects specific engineering priorities and compromises. In the current market, budget ice makers typically fall within three distinct pricing tiers:
Entry-Level ($75-$100): These models prioritize basic functionality with minimal added features. Construction typically involves substantial plastic components with selective metal accents. Performance metrics remain modest, with slightly longer ice production cycles and simplified control systems. Daily production capacity generally ranges from 20-24 pounds, while noise levels may exceed 45 dB during operation. Warranties typically cover 90 days, reflecting limited expected lifespan.
Mid-Range ($100-$150): This sweet spot represents the optimal balance between affordability and performance for most households. Construction quality improves noticeably, with better-grade plastic components and expanded metal accents. Performance metrics approach premium standards, with 6-8 minute production cycles and 24-26 pound daily capacity. Additional features often include multiple ice size options and indicator lights for maintenance needs. Warranties generally extend to 6-12 months, reflecting manufacturer confidence.
Upper Budget ($150-$200): These models approach premium performance while maintaining reasonable pricing. Construction quality demonstrates significant improvement, with expanded metal components and targeted reinforcement at wear points. Performance metrics match or exceed premium standards, with 6-7 minute production cycles and consistent 26+ pound daily capacity. Advanced features often include self-cleaning functions, enhanced insulation, and intuitive control interfaces. Warranties typically cover 12-24 months, reflecting expected longevity.
Regardless of price tier, budget ice makers share fundamental operational principles. Unlike refrigerator ice makers that freeze water in fixed molds, portable units employ rotating prongs that create hollow bullet-shaped ice—a more energy-efficient process that enables rapid production cycles.
Key Features You Can Still Get Under $200
Despite their affordable pricing, today’s budget ice makers offer surprising capability in several key areas:
Fast Ice Production: Even entry-level units now produce their first batch in under 9 minutes, with mid-range and upper budget models achieving 6-7 minute cycles—approaching commercial performance. This rapid production eliminates the extended waiting periods associated with earlier generation budget machines.
Automatic Shutoff Systems: Virtually all budget models now incorporate sensors that detect when the ice basket reaches capacity, automatically pausing production to prevent overflow. This feature eliminates monitoring requirements during extended use, enhancing convenience significantly.
Self-Cleaning Functions: Once exclusive to premium models, self-cleaning capabilities now appear in several upper budget units. These systems typically employ automated water circulation to flush mineral deposits and potential bacterial growth from internal components—a significant maintenance simplification.
Selective Ice Sizing: Many mid-range and upper budget models offer multiple ice size options, typically small and large bullet configurations. This flexibility accommodates different beverage applications, from delicate cocktails to substantial cooling needs.
Portable Design: Unlike built-in refrigerator ice makers, budget countertop units require no permanent installation. Their freestanding nature enables flexible placement and simplified seasonal storage—ideal for space-constrained environments or seasonal use patterns.
Limitations of Budget Models
Despite impressive advances, budget ice makers retain certain limitations compared to their premium counterparts:
Limited Insulation: Budget models typically incorporate minimal insulation in their ice storage compartments. This deficiency accelerates melting, with most units maintaining frozen conditions for only 2-3 hours before recycling begins. For continuous service, regular ice transfer to external freezer storage remains necessary.
Modest Storage Capacity: Most budget models accommodate only 1.5-2 pounds of ice before requiring emptying—significantly less than premium alternatives. This limitation necessitates more frequent attendance during heavy use scenarios like entertaining.
Basic Material Selection: While functional, the predominantly plastic construction of budget models lacks the durability and aesthetic appeal of premium stainless steel alternatives. Wear points like hinges and drainage components may demonstrate limited longevity with frequent use.
Minimal Filtration: Few budget models incorporate water filtration systems, relying instead on manual water quality control. This limitation may impact ice clarity and taste when using problematic water sources, potentially requiring pre-filtered water for optimal results.
Shorter Operational Lifespan: With simplified components and materials, budget ice makers typically provide 2-4 years of regular service before potential failure—approximately half the expected lifespan of premium alternatives. This shorter horizon should factor into purchasing decisions for high-frequency users.
Final Thoughts: Is a Budget Ice Maker Worth It?
After testing dozens of ice makers at various price points, I can confidently say that budget ice makers under $200 offer excellent value for most homes. While they lack some premium features, these affordable machines deliver reliable ice production for everyday needs. They’re perfect for casual users, renters, students, and anyone who doesn’t want to overspend. The best models freeze quickly, run quietly, and last 2-4 years with proper care. Unless you entertain frequently or need specialty ice types, there’s simply no need to spend more. With the right maintenance, these budget-friendly appliances provide years of convenient ice production without breaking the bank.
